International observation: the world order is moving from hegemony to inclusive multilateralism.
The end of hegemonic order is one of the most important changes in the world in the past century. Although the COVID-19 epidemic is not the cause of this change, it is a clear sign of the end of hegemony. Bipolar has become a hot topic at present, but the basic material and institutional conditions for the formation of bipolar pattern do not exist, and the torn world of binary opposition has no legal basis, and it is not accepted by China and the United States. It is difficult to form a world order with bipolar confrontation as the main axis. The era of a pluralistic world is beginning, and its typical characteristics are multipolar power pattern, multi-layer institutional arrangement and multi-dimensional ideas. For a post-hegemonic world, inclusive multilateralism is a reasonable and appropriate order form.
The end of hegemony
The COVID-19 outbreak marks the end of American hegemony, as well as the end of hegemonic era and hegemonic order.
Hegemonic order needs three kinds of power as its foundation, namely, material power, institutional power and legal power. Material power refers to visible power resources, such as economic power, military power, scientific and technological power, etc. Super material power is the material basis of hegemony. Institutional power refers to the ability to establish and operate an international system. Defining international issues, setting international agendas and implementing international actions through the international system are all manifestations of institutional power. The hegemonic order needs a universally applicable system as the operating mechanism of the order. Legitimate power refers to the ability of hegemonic countries to make the international community generally accept hegemonic order. Today’s world is an international society with rules and norms. It is impossible for a purely material power to support a hegemonic order, and mandatory governance will not run smoothly. Any international order needs legitimacy, that is, it has the full support of the international community.
The three powers constitute the necessary, sufficient and tolerant conditions of hegemony, and the hegemonic order is the construction of the trinity of the three powers. A hegemonic country with super strength is a necessary condition, an international system led by hegemonic countries is a sufficient condition, and an international society that generally accepts the ideas and systems of hegemonic countries is a tolerant condition. Without any of them, the hegemonic order could not be established and operated.
After the end of World War II, it was the landing moment and construction period of American hegemonic order. The United States began to show these three powers, but due to the beginning of the Cold War, its power did not radiate to the whole world. After the end of the Cold War, American hegemony began to cover the whole world, and reached its peak after 20 years. Material power, institutional power and legal power all pointed to the so-called "unipolar moment" of the United States, which is the stage of American world hegemony in the general sense.
The world financial crisis in 2008 is not only the peak of American hegemonic order, but also the beginning of the abdication of American hegemonic order. Since then, several important conditions of hegemonic order have begun to dissolve. The strength foundation of the hegemonic order has been seriously challenged, and the multipolar pattern of the world has become increasingly obvious; The institutional power of the United States continues to weaken, especially the wanton destruction of the international system by the Trump administration, which makes the institutional power of the United States suddenly decline; The legitimacy of hegemonic order has also been seriously challenged. Neither hegemonic stability theory nor "peace under the United States" is enough to make the world willingly accept any form of hegemonic order.
COVID-19 epidemic, as an important time node, marks the end of American hegemonic order. At the same time, it also marks the end of the hegemonic era. No single country can fully have three powers to support and operate the hegemonic order, and the global society in today’s era will not accept new hegemony. There is no hegemony after COVID-19.

The myth of two poles
After the end of the hegemonic order, a recurring view is that the bipolar confrontation order between China and the United States will replace American hegemony and the new cold war between China and the United States will dominate the world.
The world order with bipolar confrontation as its core is fully discussed in western international relations theory. Realism theory is a theory about conflict and confrontation, especially focusing on the competition among great powers. The theory of power transfer, Thucydides Trap, the tragedy of great power politics, etc. are all typical narratives of bipolar hegemony. The newly emerging new cold war discourse extends this power hegemony to the panorama of confrontation struggle. In 2020, The New York Times published a signed article entitled "The Ideological Struggle Escalates, and the United States and China Slip into the New Cold War". Pompeo delivered a speech in Nixon Library on the topic of "Communist China and the Future of the Free World", bluntly regarded China as an ideological threat and called on the free world to form a new alliance against China.
Whether it is "new poles" or "new cold war", it is far from the reality of today’s world. Referring to the Cold War between the United States and the Soviet Union, we can find some important conditions for the formation of bipolar order: First, there are two diametrically opposed ideologies and values, both of which regard themselves as the only universally correct ideas, and their ultimate goal is to defeat and destroy each other. Second, there are two opposing and relatively balanced core countries and their respective power groups. The two power groups are dominated by the core countries, and the strength between the core countries is relatively balanced. Third, there are two sets of opposing international institutional systems. Furthermore, two opposing ideas, two opposing forces and two opposing systems also form two divided and opposing international societies, which directly create the polarization of the international community and the polarization of the world. The Berlin Wall is not only a physical barrier, but also a highly symbolic isolation symbol.
In today’s world, these factors either do not exist or do not exist completely, which is not enough to form a world pattern of bipolar confrontation and a world order dominated by bipolar. China and the United States do have very different ideologies and values, but confrontation can only be formed when both ideologies try to overwhelm and destroy the other. The United States has a strong sense of the Messiah, but China does not regard its own ideology as a "universal value" to promote. China’s material power is growing rapidly and approaching that of the United States, but the gap is still obvious, and it is difficult to form extreme opposition in today’s world only by material power. Discourse power and institutional power need to be considered in an integrated way. Accordingly, the distribution of comprehensive strength is still not enough to form a pattern of bipolar confrontation. Moreover, it is almost impossible to form two alliance systems dominated by core countries in today’s world, even extremely loose or quasi-alliance systems are difficult to appear. Most countries in the world will not easily choose sides, let alone re-establish alliances with big countries. Bipolar order, like hegemonic order, will not be recognized by the international community and has no legal significance in today’s world.
There is also a crucial point. Considering the global development trend and their respective national strategies, both Chinese and American governments will not recognize the bipolar world order. What the United States wants is to lead the world again, not to compete with China. As far as China is concerned, the new bipolar relationship between China and the United States and the new Cold War both violate the strategic declaration of not seeking hegemony and do not conform to the ideal and belief of building a community of human destiny. China’s basic goal and supreme interests are the great cause of national rejuvenation, and its hegemonic position is not the symbol of national rejuvenation, so there is no causal relationship between them. The two poles with clear boundaries and competitive conflicts are particularly unfavorable to China’s current development and the great cause of national rejuvenation. Therefore, promoting multipolarization conforms to the trend of world development and is also a wise strategic choice and action at present.
The strategic competition between China and the United States may intensify under certain conditions and will continue for quite some time, but the bipolar pattern and the bipolar-dominated world order are still difficult to emerge. A torn world is not good for anyone, so it will not be accepted by the vast majority of members of the international community. Hegemony and bipolarity, a highly centralized power structure, run counter to the general trend of the world. The new bipolarity and the new cold war are more a fantasy of power politics and a myth of conceptual confrontation. There is no bipolar after hegemony.
Pluralistic world and inclusive multilateralism
The post-hegemonic era presents a pluralistic world, a multipolar, multi-layered and multi-dimensional compound world.
Multipole refers to the polycentric state of the power pattern. From the perspective of material power, China, the United States and the European Union are three relatively stable power centers, and important international actors such as Russia, India and ASEAN also constitute power sub-centers. At the same time, the role of other international actors, such as international organizations, multinational corporations and transnational social networks, is becoming increasingly obvious, especially in setting the world agenda and spreading ideas. Such an overall power pattern will persist for a long time, and it is impossible for any single country to gain the power advantage of comprehensively leading international affairs.
Multilayer refers to the multilevel state of the international system. The international institutional arrangements in the hegemonic order are concentrated at the level of the international system, and the power in the post-hegemonic world is more dispersed, and the institutional arrangements will develop to multiple levels and fields. Taking global governance as an example, institutional arrangements at the regional level will be more active, and it will be easier to reach agreements and solve practical problems; Issue-oriented institutional arrangements will be strengthened in some important areas, and climate change, public health and network security are becoming the key areas of global governance. A more three-dimensional and multifaceted international system and governance form will become an important symbol of a pluralistic world.
Multidimensional refers to the multidimensional state of ideas. In the post-hegemonic world, the multi-dimension and diversity of ideas have become very obvious, and the mainstream ideology and ideas have become more diverse than ever before. For important issues such as governance model, development path and institutional mechanism, the pluralistic situation is becoming increasingly obvious. Furthermore, these ideas of mainstream ideology are more of a kind of coexistence competition, rather than a life-and-death struggle between the two values of the United States and the Soviet Union during the Cold War for independence.
Multi-polar, multi-layered and multi-dimensional complex is the reality of the present world, and the most likely and most orderly thing in the world is inclusive multilateralism.
Inclusive multilateralism adheres to the basic principles of multilateralism, including building and maintaining a peaceful and stable world order in accordance with the international system rather than power; Managing world affairs through consultation on multilateral platforms rather than coercion; International cooperation is achieved through policy coordination between countries rather than threats or even force; Balance national interests and global interests under multilateral conditions, cultivate global civic awareness and prevent the tragedy of the global commons.
Inclusive multilateralism follows the practical principle that there is no exception in the world, that is, from a global perspective, all members of the international community are regarded as equal members in the community of destiny, and the self-exclusion of the other is eliminated with community consciousness. Inclusive multilateralism adheres to the inclusive value orientation and recognizes that the world today is a pluralistic complex with different civilizations, cultures, religious beliefs, social systems and ideas. Regard the coexistence and symbiosis of different values as the normal state, regard differences as the conditions of life prosperity, transcend ideology and seek a positive way to get along. Inclusive multilateralism practices the decision-making process of democratic consultation. In the post-hegemonic period, no country has the ability to set rules for the world and support the effective operation of the international system, and the pluralistic situation of the international community will not accept the legitimacy of any country leading international affairs. The decision-making process of democratic consultation requires the members of the international community, especially the big countries, to carry out consultation and coordination that is beneficial to the global commons, and all relevant members should consult together to reform, formulate and implement the international system on the basis of consultation.
American hegemony as an order has ended, and the world has entered a truly pluralistic era. The end of a world order may bring two completely different results: one is disorder and system failure; The other is to carry forward the past and promote progress. The world today is at such a crossroads. If members of the international community can’t get out of the trap of power politics, transcend ideological differences and properly coordinate the relationship between the world and countries, it is possible to return to power politics, populism and unilateralism, and the world can only be a more unsafe place and a more unsuitable place for human beings to live and coexist. Only by recognizing the reality of a pluralistic world, cultivating the consciousness of a community of human destiny, finding the way that different countries, different nationalities and different values are compatible, harmonious and symbiotic, and building a world order with inclusive multilateralism as its pillar can the world implement effective governance and establish a peaceful, prosperous and progressive order.
(The author is a professor and doctoral supervisor at Foreign Affairs University. The article was originally published in Asia-Pacific Security and Ocean Research, No.2, 2021, with a full text of about 18,000 words.)
Reporting/feedback